AMCHA Co-founders Call on San Francisco State University Dean to Condemn Faculty Group Glorifying the Murder of Jews

 

From: Tammi Benjamin <tammi@amchainitiative.org>
Date: November 21, 2013 2:24:06 PM PST
To: Kenneth P Monteiro <monteiro@sfsu.edu>
Cc: President's Office <presidnt@sfsu.edu>, Timothy White <twhite@calstate.edu>, Leticia Hernandez <lhernandez@calstate.edu>, Andrew Jones <gajones@calstate.edu>, Rabab Ibrahim Abdulhadi <ria55@sfsu.edu>, president@asi.sfsu.edu, Guy Dalpe <gdalpe@sfsu.edu>, senator.leno@senate.ca.gov, senator.yee@senate.ca.gov, assemblymember.ting@assembly.ca.gov, senator.liu@senate.ca.gov, Assemblymember.Buchanan@assembly.ca.gov, Jennifer Gorovitz <JenniferG@sfjcf.org>, Doug Kahn <dkahn@jcrc.org>, rabbibrandt@jfed.org, myrna@jfed.org, jyl@jvalley.org, diane@jvalley.org, acushnir@jewishla.org, Melissa Chapman <mchapman@jewishsac.org>, Jessica Braverman Birch <jbirch@jewishsac.org>, lenmf1@yahoo.com, michaels@ujfsd.org, lindaf@jewishfederationsandiego.org, shalom@jfoc.org, chelle@jfoc.org, msrassler@sbjf.org, skatz@sbjf.org, dgoldfarb@jewishlongbeach.org, Mervyn Danker <dankerm@ajc.org>, greenebaumg@ajc.org, Ari Hier <iact@wiesenthal.com>, Rabbi Abraham Cooper <acooper@wiesenthal.com>, Rabbi Meyer May <rabbimay@wiesenthal.com>, Roz Rothstein ~ SWU <roz@standwithus.com>, Orit Arfa <Oarfa@zoa.org>, Jesse Rosenblum <rosenblumjh@msn.com>, sandiego@zoa.org, Sam Levine <SLevine@zoa.org>, marving@sfjcf.org, rabbi@mjcs.org, kalinsky@aol.com, schapira@uscj.org, BoardofRabbis@JewishLA.org, vsalama@jcrc.org, julie@jpac-cal.org, MCARR@ADL.ORG, ngrotch@adl.org, kogrady@adl.org, mcasuto@adl.org, csilverman@adl.org, sbrysk@adl.org, asusskind@adl.org, MarshaH@sfjcf.org, Ryan Pessah <capitolknesset@gmail.com>, director@sfhillel.org, Leila Beckwith <Leila@AMCHAinitiative.org>
Subject: Request to condemn AMED-linked Facebook message

Dear Dean Monteiro,

As you know, last week AMCHA Iniaitive sent a letter to President Wong expressing our concern over an event sponsored by the Arab and Muslim Ethnicities and Diasporas Initiative in the College of Ethnic Studies, that occurred on November 7.  At that event, students were encouraged to engage in art projects which involved using a stencil bearing the image of a notorious terrorist and another stencil that stated “MY HEROES HAVE ALWAYS KILLED COLONIZERS.”

It has come to our attention that following our letter to President Wong, which was copied to you and to AMED Senior Scholar Rabab Abdulhadi, a statement clearly linked to AMED was posted on Facebook (see below), bearing the header:

“Zionists: Hands off our San Francisco State University Students!”

“Support AMED and GUPS against a Zionist smear campaign/charges of Anti-Semitism”

We believe the Facebook statement was, at least in part, written by an AMED faculty member.

The Facebook statement, which makes clear that AMED and GUPS were responsible for the two stencils, is a defense of the stencils and an ad hominem attack on AMCHA Initiative for raising legitimate concerns about their antisemitic nature.

Please understand that this AMED-linked Facebook statement defends, justifies, and glorifies murder and those who commit it.

President Wong has unambiguously condemned this behavior.

Therefore, we ask you to do the same:

Please issue a public condemnation of student and faculty groups and individuals affiliated with the College of Ethnic Studies, who use the name and resources of the University to defend, justify, and glorify murder and those who commit it.

We and the concerned Jewish community eagerly await your statement.

Sincerely,

Tammi Rossman-Benjamin
Co-founder, AMCHA Initiative

Leila Beckwith
Co-founder, AMCHA Initiative

Cc:
SFSU President Leslie Wong
CSU Chancellor Timothy P. White
CSU Board of Trustees
CSU Interim General Counsel Andrew Jones
Professor Rabab Abdulhadi, Senior Scholar, AMED
Andrenike Hamilton, President SFSU Associated Students, Inc.
Guy Dalpe, Managing Director Cesar Chavez Student Center
California State Senator Leland Y. Yee (San Francisco)
California State Senator Mark Leno  (San Francisco)
California Assembly Member Philip Y. Ting (San Francisco)
California Assembly Member Joan Buchanan, Chair of the Assembly Education Committee
California Jewish community leaders

BCC: Wide circulation in the Jewish community

*********************

AMED-linked Facebook Posting

https://www.facebook.com/zbarghouti/posts/10102620779758163

Posted by  Zachariah Mohammad Yacoub-Rabah Barghouti

Zionists: Hands off our San Francisco State University Students!Support AMED and GUPS against a Zionist smear campaign/charges of Anti-SemitismDear Friends of AMED and GUPS:This is an urgent message to make you aware of and call upon you to support the Arab and Muslim Ethnicities and Diasporas Initiative (AMED) and the General Union of Palestine Students (GUPS) at San Francisco State University. We have been subjected to a smear campaign by Tammi Benjamin and AMCHA Initiative.In an email to SFSU President that was copied to members of the California legislature, San Francisco Board of Supervisors, and countless others (please see below), Benjamin claimed that the November 7th event commemorating the 6th anniversary of the Palestinian Cultural Mural honoring the late Professor Edward Said, We Speak for Ourselves: Honoring our Forbearers, was “an anti-Semitic on-campus activity that encourages students to glorify the murder of Jews.” To support her unfounded claims, Benjamin refers to two stencils on a table in the Malcolm X Plaza during the afternoon of the event one is of Leila Khaled and the other inscribed with the statement, MY HEROES HAVE ALWAYS KILLED COLONIZERS.Aiming at invoking xenophobia and enlisting the “war on terror” in order to portray Palestinian campus activism as dangerous, illegal and outside the bounds of acceptable discourse, Benjamin refers to Leila Khaled as “a member of the U.S. State Department-designated terrorist organization Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP)…. responsible for several plane hijackings, suicide bombings that killed several Jews, and the assassination of a Jewish member of the Israeli Knesset.” Had she done a quick search as academics usually do, Benjamin would have found that Leila Khaled’s image is a popular icon frequently used by Palestinians and non-Palestinians alike to symbolize Palestinian women’s roles in anti-colonial resistance and to counter Orientalist and racist portrayals of Arab (and Muslim) women as docile, oppressed and unable to speak for themselves.

As a matter of fact, a few years ago, following the meeting of the SFSU Curriculum Review and Approval Committee (CRAC) that discussed and approved the Minor in Race and Resistance Studies (RRS), students and faculty of RRS gathered outside the meeting room to take a group photo to be posted on our website. RRS students unfurled a banner that they had made a long time ago on which Leila Khaled’s picture was stenciled. I asked the students then to put away the banner lest an impression is formed that I was behind it, being mindful of exactly the sort of smearing campaigns Benjamin has now undertaken. I recall that both RRS students and faculty laughed it away, probably thinking that I was exaggerating the effect of holding up such a banner and insisted on keeping it in the group photo. The Benjamin attack is yet another proof that we (people who support justice for/in Palestine) will continue to be targeted for our political stands.

As for the second stencil MY HEROES HAVE ALWAYS KILLED COLONIZERS, contrary to Benjamin’s claim, Palestinian students were not calling for the murder of Jews or Israelis. In fact, the implication of Benjamin’s argument –that all Jews have the same political stands vis-à-vis Israel or that all Jews are colonizing Palestinian lands, lends itself to anti-Semitism. And notwithstanding her simplistic linkage of Said’s anti-colonial intellectual work, the Palestinian Mural anniversary, Palestinian students, and AMED, the stencil was not originally created to specifically target Israel. It was more inclusive of the plight of Indigenous people and their historical resistance everywhere.

The stencil was made by Indigenous activists for an event marking the anniversary of genocide in the Americashttps://www.facebook.com/events/521584261240884/ on October 14, 2013. Posted on the Native American Indian Networkhttps://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/bay-area-native-american-indian-network/udfjGGr5Mi4/TJNmLPvAIAoJ as the Second Annual

‘My HEROES Have Always Killed Colonizers: Stories of Global Indigenous REZistance’, the event aimed at countering the depiction of the “Indigenous warrior who has been labeled a terrorist, unpatriotic, and/or savage while defending the land, the people, and our traditional ways.”

The announcement of the event was also reproduced on the website of the Global Exchange

. Silk screening was only a part of the event that included:

[A] night of song, words, and resistance, a celebration of every global indigenous warrior who’s been labeled a terrorist, unpatriotic, and/or savage while defending the land, the people, and our traditional ways. Through storytelling, spoken word and performance we will collectively Re-Indigenize our heroes, such as Leila Khaled, Boukman, Lapu-Lapu, Toy Purina and Geromino so that they may claim their true role in history.

Finally, the November 7th Palestinian Mural Anniversary was not solely sponsored by GUPS and AMED, as Benjamin implies in order to isolate and target Palestinian activists. All the Murals on the walls of the Cesar Chavez Student Center http://www.sfsustudentcenter.com/about/murals.php belong to the student center, including the murals of Cesar Chavez, Malcolm X, the Indian, Filipino and Native American struggles, and they all reflect student commitment to and activism on questions of justice relevant to struggles in their communities.

The Palestinian Cultural Mural honoring the late Professor Edward Said http://www.sfsustudentcenter.com/about/murals.php#palestinianmural, inaugurated on November 2, 2007, the birthday of Edward Said, was the direct result of a long and difficult but successful campaign by a broad coalition of students, faculty, and staff at SFSU, working hand in hand with community members and organizations. Led by the General Union of Palestinian Students (GUPS), the coalition included other student groups, such as the Student Kouncil for Intertribal Nations (SKINS) that was founded by Richard Oakes, the Indigenous student who in 1968 led the take-over of Alcatraz; Black Student Union (BSU) that, along with the 3rd World Liberation Front (TWLF), led the successful 1968 Student Strike for a College for 3rd World Studies at SFSU; as well as other student groups that have been part of the rich history of San Francisco State University, such as the League of Filipino Students (LFS), La Raza Student Organization, and Movemento Estadiantil Chicano De Aztlan (MeCHA). The Deans of the College of Ethnic Studies, Ken Monteiro, and the College of Education, Jake Perea were instrumental in the success of the mural. Activists and organizations in the Palestinian, Arab and Muslim communities, Indigenous communities and communities of color, as well as anti-Zionist Jewish organizations, civil liberties, trade unions and feminist and queer groups, united around the principle of justice for Palestine as an integral and an organic part of justice for all, came together to insist that the mural see the light after a battle that lasted several years during which a strong campaign was unsuccessfully waged by the Jewish Community Relations Council and other SF Bay Area Zionist organizations against the mural and for that matter any campus presence of Palestine.

The history of the Palestinian mural at SFSU with its broad based coalition of communal and campus alliances, on one hand, and the multiple sites that clearly show that that the stencil originated with Native American activism and spoke about colonized people everywhere, on the other, debunk the most recent slander campaign of Benjamin and Company. Why would Benjamin and AMCHA then ignore all these facts and insist on smearing Palestinian activism?

 

As the movement for justice in/for Palestine gains grounds and grows broader beyond the Palestinian, Arab and Muslim communities, Benjamin and Company have escalated their campaign. Their goals are to arrive at an official position that equates criticism of Israel with anti-Semitism in order to discredit us and prevent us from speaking up. When they fail to do so, as the HR 35 affair shows, they try to manipulate the truth and exact statements of condemnation from university officials by making a lot of noise and mobilizing their list-serves to create the impression that lack of statements amounts to acceptance of anti-Semitism. When all else fails, their last resort is to make enough noise to keep us occupied so we won’t have the time or energy to speak up for the truth.

Benjamin and her group are not looking for constructive discussion. All they seek to do is silence speech on justice for/in Palestine. What we need to do is to be firm on academic freedom and against smearing institutions, programs and faculty who support the right of students to organize ourselves, speak our minds and pursue justice wherever injustice occurs and irrespective of the powerful groups that seek to silence us.

What you can do to support GUPS and AMED:
1. Attend an emergency meeting called for by GUPS and its allies tonight, Tuesday, November 19th, at 6pm, in the conference room of the College of Ethnic Studies, 116 Ethnic Studies and Psychology Building, SFSU http://www.sfsu.edu/~sfsumap/
2. Write or call the office of SFSU President, Dr. Leslie E. Wong presidnt@sfsu.edu to counter the campaign waged by Benjamin and AMCHA Initiative.
3. Support GUPS statement by signing the petition ……
4. Organize events on your campus to educate and publicize the struggle for justice in/for Palestine as an indivisible part of justice for all and insist on our right to academic freedom and campus activism.

For more information, please call or email AMED at (415) 505-2668 or amedstaf@sfsu.edu or GUPS at (415) 338-1908 or sfsugups415@gmail.com.